Clever and slick but also quite thoughtful, the
made-for-TV feature Katherine depicts
the radicalization of a rich white girl from Colorado during the heyday of the
anti-Vietnam War movement. Beginning with her eye-opening experience as a
teacher of impoverished farmers living near an American mission in Peru,
Katherine Alman (Sissy Spacek) becomes more and more incensed about the social
inequities of the modern world, which naturally creates estrangement between
Katherine and her wealthy parents, Emily (Jane Wyatt) and Thornton (Art
Carney). Meanwhile, Katherine’s commitment to revolutionary change brings her
into the orbit of Bob Kline (Henry Winkler), a fellow teacher-turned-radical,
and the two eventually join the Weathermen wing of Students for a Democratic
Society. Writer-director Jeremy Paul Kagan, whose script was inspired by the
exploits of real-life SDS activist Diana Oughton, exhibits a deft touch for
blending entertainment and issues.
The best scenes in Katherine feature direct human conflict that dramatizes class
warfare, ranging from an early scene of a thuggish overseer whipping a farm
worker to a pivotal re-creation of the riots surrounding the 1968 Democratic
Convention in Chicago. Even in smaller scenes, Kagan effectively crystallizes
major political strife into relatable disagreements. For instance, the sequence
of Bob and Katherine receiving pressure from black citizens and white cops to
close the school where Bob and Katherine teach African-American youths
illustrates how many different battle lines were drawn in the late ’60s. Scenes
set in the Alman house lack the same measure of authenticity, because Kagan’s choice
to gift his character with a privileged background overstates the stereotype of
part-time radicals who retain the safety net of running home to Mom and Dad.
That said, committed acting elevates even the most contrived parts of Katherine. Carney embodies old-fashioned
American decency so beautifully that he evokes the movies of Frank Capra, and
Winkler—a long way from Fonzie thanks to his moustache and shaggy hair—imbues
his character with the beguiling/maddening blend of messianic charisma and smug
narcissism that plagued so many men in the antiwar movement. Holding the film
together, of course, is Spacek, an actor nearly incapable of striking a false
note. Even Spacek’s great powers, however, are tested by some of the strident
speeches that Kagan’s script forces her to deliver. Yet stilted dialogue isn’t
the only component of Katherine that
feels wobbly, as Kagan’s storytelling involves three layers—documentary-style
vignettes in which characters address the camera, fully dramatized re-creations
of events, and eerie clips of Katherine telling her own story. Although the
last of these three elements could have been discarded without much harm to the
film’s dramatic power, Kagan sticks the landing with a beautifully cut final
sequence that pulls all of the story’s threads together.
Katherine:
GROOVY
I loved Katherine. I thought it was super ahead of it's time, the acting was great, everything. It also struck close to home for me because of how much my mom is similar to the main character! Except for the end part....
ReplyDeleteI'm very fond of it.
ReplyDeleteYou almost expect a story full of disclaimers about how "misguided" the character is, and you don't really get that.