Like many iconic directors
who began their careers in the studio era, Otto Preminger fared poorly in the
’70s—with each successive picture, his old-fashioned style seemed more and more
disconnected from current trends. Adding to the problem was the filmmaker’s
apparent creative fatigue, because Preminger’s final films are even more static
and talky than the ones he made in his heyday, which is saying a lot. This
doesn’t mean, however, that Preminger had lost his ability find interesting material.
Quite to the contrary, the director’s last feature film, The Human Factor, is an intelligent and restrained spy thriller
adapted from a book by one of the genre’s grand masters, Graham Greene. Had a
filmmaker with more passion tackled the project, The Human Factor could have achieved a much greater impact. As is,
it’s respectable but unimpressive.
Set in England, the story concerns two MI6
analysts, Marcus Castle (Nicol Williamson) and Arthur Davis (Derek Jacobi).
Castle has settled into a quiet existence with his wife, Sarah (Iman), a former
spy whom he met while working for the UK in South Africa, and her son.
Conversely, Davis hates the dull routine of a desk job, preferring the high
life of nightclubs and women. When clues from within the USSR alert ambitious
security officer Colonel Daintry (Richard Attenborough) to a leak in MI6’s
African division, Daintry collaborates with a ruthless superior officer, Dr.
Percival (Robert Morley), on an investigation into the activities of Castle and
Davis. Describing any more of the story would reveal key plot twists, but
suffice to say that Greene’s narrative plays provocative games with duplicity,
personal agendas, and political affiliations, as well as the X factors of
bloodlust and careerism.
In fact, nearly everything about The Human Factor works except for Preminger’s direction. Tom
Stoppard’s script is intelligent, if a bit mechanical, and the cast is
excellent, with the exception of model-turned-actress Iman, who’s quite weak in
this, her debut performance. Williamson defines a believable sort of
middle-class discomfort, which is surprising to encounter in this context;
Jacobi essays a would-be swinger whose style outpaces his substance; and
Attenborough is terrific as a company man who maintains rigid control until he
realizes the dangerous repercussion of his brazen maneuvers. Morley’s
performance is a bit odd, for while he delivers lines with his usual panache,
he often seems as if he’s reading dialogue from cue cards, and the lengthy
sequence of Morley making exaggerated facial expressions while reacting to a
topless dancer is unpleasant to watch. The stripper scene is one of many that
Preminger both films unimaginatively and lets run to excessive length; these
shapeless stretches dilute the story’s potential impact.
The Human Factor eventually comes together in a credibly unresolved
sort of way, since everyone involved in the story becomes affected by
revelations and suspicions. Nonetheless, the movie isn’t nearly the elegant
descent into darkness it should have been.
The Human Factor: FUNKY
A terrible shame that this was Premingers last film. At his best he was magnificent. He seemed to lose the plot after the disaster that was 1968's Skidoo.
ReplyDeleteAll the elements are here for an excellent spy thriller, especially the cast (Nicol Williamson is IMHO one of the most underrated actors of the last century).
The only term I can come up with to describe this one is flat, in every sense.
Still, one upside, it has the legend that is Robert Morley. Even if he is reading his lines from cue cards...Hell, even if he was being poked in the butt and fed the lines by an off screen prompter, Morley is mesmerising.
Oh, and I nearly forgot...Happy 4th blogging birthday Mr Hanson. I guess you must dream in widescreen by now.