A minor work by writer-director
James Bridges—whose more impressive credits include The Paper Chase (1973) and The
China Syndrome (1979)—September 30,
1955 revolves around a bold premise that sounds more interesting in
conception than it is in execution. The titular date is when movie star James
Dean died in a car wreck, so Bridges focuses on the reactions of several Dean
fans in small-town Arkansas. The idea, so promising in the abstract, was to
convey why Dean’s incarnation of angst-ridden teen rebellion spoke so deeply to
a generation of postwar adolescents. Unfortunately, Bridges stretches this
already-thin material way past its breaking point, and he features characters
whose behavior is so extreme (and inexplicable) that he leaves recognizable
reality far behind. Perhaps Bridges would have been better served tackling this
topic with a short film.
In any event, the central character of September 30, 1955 is Jimmy (Richard
Thomas), a high-strung youth afraid of the life that awaits him after he
graduates high school in a few weeks. Having fallen under Dean’s thrall after
seeing East of Eden (1955) four
times, Jimmy is more than eager to demonstrate that he, too, can be a rebel.
Hearing about Dean’s death gives Jimmy license to release his id, so the
picture depicts the misguided mischief Jimmy creates along with friends
including Charlotte (Deborah Benson), Frank (Dennis Quaid), Hanley (Tom Hulce),
and especially Billie Jean (Lisa Blount), who’s an even bigger Dean freak than
Jimmy. The youths steal booze from a store, run away from cops, hold a séance,
terrorize classmates at a lover’s-lane spot, and eventually trigger a
near-tragic accident. While it’s easy to believe that Jimmy’s friends are bored
kids looking for laughs, accepting Jimmy’s characterization is nearly
impossible—whether he’s stripping down to undies and slathering himself in mud
or claiming he’s receiving signals from Dean’s spirit, Jimmy comes across as a
lunatic. He’s also a boring lunatic,
especially in the film’s interminable climactic scene, which features Jimmy
giving the dullest monologue imaginable in an utterly absurd circumstance.
Thomas, who enjoyed a big ’70s TV career on The
Waltons, wears out his welcome here, reaching for but not seizing the kind
of intensity that seemed to come effortlessly for better Dean-esque actors
(e.g., Martin Sheen, etc.). Thomas’ castmates fare better, but they can’t fully
surmount the iffy material, and an atrocious score by Leonard Rosenman only
makes things worse. Only the great cinematographer Gordon Willis contributes
something unassailably special to September
30, 1955, with moody imagery dominated by shadows and silhouettes, although
whether his dark style is actually “right” for this story is anybody’s guess.
September 30, 1955: FUNKY
2 comments:
What about Rosenman's score did you find atrocious? I haven't seen the film in several years, but seem to recall Rosenman re-using his score from East of Eden, and it was an estimable score, at least originally.
That factoid (of which I was not aware) relates to why I disliked the music, which struck me as oversized to the point of grandiosity. Knowing now that the music was originally scaled to highly pitched performances, I can see why it felt wrong to me when accompanying quieter, more grounded performances. I must confess to not being a Roseman fan in general; while he's done some work I can clinically observe to be fine, he shares with Pino Donaggio, to my ears, a lack of restraint. And before anyone calls me on my appreciation for vintage John Williams, not always the subtlest of scorers, I return to the idea of scale; bad Williams, for instance, smothers small scenes in goopy strings, whereas great Williams elevates exciting scenes with appropriate bombast. All very much a taste thing, of course.
Post a Comment