A great example of the microcosm revealing the macrocosm,
this insightful documentary examines antiwar demonstrations that erupted in and
around the college town of Madison, Wisconsin, throughout the Vietnam War. In
so doing, the film speaks to the larger issues that divided the entire nation
during that fraught era. Filled with amazing archival footage—it seems as if
every key event in the Madison peace movement was caught on camera—the picture
is neatly divided into sections depicting specific years, so the narrative
stretches from the earliest outcries in the mid-’60s to a violent revolt that
shook the Madison community in the early ’70s. Right from the beginning of the
picture, poignant moments abound. During a public hearing in the mid-’60s, for
instance, a housewife named Louise Smalley testifies to local officials that
she’s aghast by the notion of American troops dropping napalm on Vietnamese
villages: “I try to teach my children the value of individual human worth, and
I don’t want this destroyed by my country.”
Just as that remark summarizes
conscientious objections to the war, another comment symbolizes why so many
college students mobilized—a student laments that the escalation of hostilities
means middle-class kids will be subject to the draft, “not just poor kids.”
Ouch. To the great credit of producers Glenn Silber (who also directed) and
Barry Alexander Brown, The War at Home never seems judgmental of the implied
elitist stance behind such remarks; rather, the film makes a compelling
argument that the draft became a social equalizer, uniting potential draftees
against the military-industrial complex. As a banner that’s shown onscreen
reads, “To be against the war and do nothing is irresponsible.”
It’s
fascinating, then, to learn about the actions that people in Madison actually
took. Some demonstrations seem pointless, almost to the extreme of being
counter-productive, like heckling Teddy Kennedy during a 1966 campus
appearance, while others are more purposeful, such as an SDS rally against Dow
Chemical’s practice of on-campus recruiting. (Dow made napalm.) The filmmakers
wisely keep their focus local, spreading the view to the larger national
antiwar milieu only when appropriate—one bit describes how protesters from
Wisconsin traveled to the infamous 1968 Democratic National Convention in
Chicago. Similarly, the filmmakers largely eschew celebrities of the
counterculture era. Even though the soundtrack features the requisite mix of
Buffalo Springfield and Dylan, et cetera, hipster poet Allen Ginsberg is the
only famous figure featured in an original interview. (Presidents Ford and
Nixon, among other political notables, appear only in archival footage.)
The
War at Home culminates with vivid commentary from participants in a fatal campus
bombing that represented a misguided attempt to derail on-campus military
research. One of the convicted bombers, Karlton Armstrong, appears on-camera to
explain his motivations, and then, in a bracing moment, Armstrong’s Greatest
Generation father acknowledges how successfully antiwar activists were in
bringing ugly realities to light. “They were telling the truth,” the father
says. “We weren’t listening.”
The War at Home: RIGHT ON
No comments:
Post a Comment